Sad and Sordid Whereabouts of bin Cheney and bin Bush"
A Free Online Chapter addition to "Stupid White Men"
by Michael Moore
"What Does a 99-cent Bic Lighter Tell Us
About the Bush War on Terrorism?"
On September 22, 2001, just 11 days after the terrorist attacks
in New York and Arlington, I had to fly. I had actually wanted to
fly on September 11, and in fact had a ticket on the 3:00pm American
Airlines flight from LAX to JFK. As we all know, that flight never
made it off the ground as hours earlier four California-bound flights,
two on American and two on United, were hijacked as part of a coordinated
suicide mission to attack the World Trade Center in New York City
and the Pentagon outside Washington, DC.
Stranded in Los Angeles, my wife and I (out there for the annual
Prime Time Emmy Awards for our series, "The Awful Truth"), were
awakened that morning by my wife's mother, calling us from Flint
at 6:15 a.m., L.A. time. I answered the phone and heard her say
that "New York was under attack, New York is at war." I remember
thinking, "So what's new," but she suggested we immediately turn
on the TV. I fumbled for the remote and switched on the hotel room
TV. And there it was. The twin towers on fire, black smoke billowing
"OK," I thought, "a really bad fire." But then they ran the replay
from 15 minutes earlier, of the second plane hitting the south tower.
This wasn't an accident. We tried to call our daughter in New York.
The phone lines weren't allowing any calls. We tried calling our
friend, Joanne Doroshow, who works a few blocks from the towers.
Again, the lines were jammed.
A horrible panic started settling inside me. Finally, I reached
Joanne's office. A woman answered, frantic. I asked if Joanne was
there. "NO!" she shouted. "She's not here! We have to go! Ohmygod!"
She dropped the phone and I heard a loud roar, like a train. My
wife said, "Look at the TV." I did, and I saw from L.A. what I was
listening to over the phone: the collapse of the south tower.
It would be another four hours before we were able to reach our
daughter, and seven hours before Joanne calls us, safe inside her
apartment (she had ducked into a building just in time as the cloud
of debris rained its way down the street).
That night, as we watched the images repeated on the TV, a ticker
began running the names of some of the dead who had been on the
planes. Along the bottom of the screen came the name, "William Weems."
A friend of ours the next morning confirmed that this was, in fact,
the same Bill Weems, a line producer from Boston with whom we had
recently filmed a batch of humorous TV spots targeting the tobacco
companies. Bill was on the Boston-to-L.A. plane. He died as the
jet, traveling at 586 miles per hour, slammed into the south tower.
He left behind a wife and 7-year old daughter. It was all so unbelievably
The airports were closed and all planes were now grounded. I found
a Hertz dealer who would rent me a mini-van for $1,700 -- and 43
hours later we pulled out of our hotel on the Pacific Ocean and
began our 2,990-mile journey home to our apartment in New York City.
Somewhere around Oklahoma City, the airports were all open again,
but my wife did not want to ditch the mini-van and get on a plane.
So we continued on home for the next few days, the first ever trip
each of us had made driving coast to coast. It was, as it turned
out, well worth it, as it gave us a chance to gauge the reaction
of average citizens, especially as we passed through Bush and Ashcroft
country (The internet letters I wrote – and
read – from the road can be found on my website).
By September 22, I had no choice but to get back on a plane. I
had been scheduled to give a talk in San Antonio, and so off I went
on an American flight out of Newark. At the airport there was a
newly, hastily put-together list of all the items that I could NOT
bring aboard the plane. The list was long and bizarre. The list
of banned items included:
No guns. (Obviously)
No knives. (Ditto)
No boxcutters. (Certainly now justified)
No toenail clippers. (What?)
No knitting needles. (Huh?)
No crotchet hooks. (Now, wait a minute!)
No sewing needles.
No leaf blowers. (OK, now it's personal)
No letter openers.
No dry ice.
The list went on and on. A lot of the items made good sense. I
wasn't quite sure if terrorists also made quilts in their spare
time, and I guess I must have missed the terrorist incident where
some poor bastards smuggled dry ice aboard a plane (were they trying
to keep their Popsicles cold until they ate them and then used the
sticks for their attack?).
Frankly, I was a little freaked-out about flying so soon after
9-11 and I guess there was just no way I was going to fly without
a weapon for my protection. So I took the New York Yankees-signed
baseball that Mayor Giuliani had given me on "TV Nation," put it
in a sock, and – presto! Whip that baby upside somebody's
head, and they're going to take a little nap. Note to budding terrorfuckers:
If you try something on a flight I'm on, I'll Clemens ya. That,
or the smell from my ratty sock, is going to do you in.
Though I now felt "safe" with my makeshift weapon, as I continued
to fly through the fall and winter, I did NOT feel safe being greeted
at airport security by weekend warriors from the National Guard
holding empty M-16s and looking like they shop in the same "special
needs" department at K-Mart which I visit from time to time.
More importantly, though, I kept noticing something strange. The
guy in front of me, while emptying his pockets into the little plastic
tray to run through the x-ray machine, would take out his butane
lighter or matchbook, toss them into the tray, then pick them up
on the other side -- in full view of security. At first I thought
this was a mistake until I looked at the list of banned items again
-- and saw that butane lighters and matchbooks were NOT on the forbidden
Then came December 22, 2001. Richard Reid, on an American Airlines
flight from Paris to Miami, attempted to light his shoes on fire,
using matches. His shoes, the police said, contained a plastic explosive
and, had some passengers and flight attendants not taken quick action
to restrain him, he would have been able to blow the entire plane
out of the sky. But his lighter would not light the shoes fast enough,
and everyone survived.
I was sure after this freakish incident that the lighters and
matches would surely be banned. But, as my book tour began in February,
there they were, the passengers with their Bic lighters and their
books of matches. I asked one security person after another why
these people were allowed to bring devices which could start a fire
on board the plane, especially after the Reid incident. No one,
not a single person in authority or holding an unloaded automatic
weapon, could or would give me answer.
My simple question was this: If all smoking is prohibited on all
flights, then why does ANYONE need their lighters and matches at
30,000 feet -- while I am up there with them?!
And why is the one device that has been used to try and blow up
a plane since 9-11 NOT on the banned list? No one has used toenail
clippers to kill anyone on Jet Blue, and no one has been blowing
away the leaves in the aisle of the Delta Connection flight to Tupelo.
BUT SOME FRUITCAKE DID USE A BUTANE LIGHTER TO TRY AND KILL 200
PEOPLE ON AMERICAN AIRLINES FLIGHT #63. And this did nothing to
force the Bush Administration to do something about it.
I began asking this question in front of audiences on my book
tour. And it was on a dark and rainy night in Arlington, Virginia,
at the Ollsson's Bookstore a couple miles from the Pentagon that
I got my answer. After asking my Bic lighter question in my talk
to the audience, I sat down to sign the books for the people in
line. A young man walks up to the table, introduces himself, and
lowering his voice so no one can hear, tells me the following:
"I work on the Hill. The butane lighters were on the original
list prepared by the FAA and sent to the White House for approval.
The tobacco industry lobbied the Bush administration to have the
lighters and matches removed from the banned list. Their customers
(addicts) naturally are desperate to light up as soon as they land,
and why should they be punished just so the skies can be safe?
The lighters and matches were removed from the forbidden list.
I was stunned. I knew there had to be some strange reason why
this most obvious of items had not been banned. Could the Bush mob
be so blatant in their contempt for the public's safety? How could
they do this, and at the same time, issue weekly warnings about
the "next terrorist threat"? Would they really put Big Tobacco's
demands ahead of people's lives?
Yes, of course, the answer has always been YES but not now, not
in a time of national crisis, not NOW, so soon after the worst domestic
mass murder in U.S. history!
Unless there was no real threat at all.
The hard and difficult questions must be asked: Is the "War on
Terrorism" a ruse, a concoction to divert the citizens' attention?
Accept, if you will for just a moment, that as truly despicable
as George W. Bush is, he would not be so evil as to help out his
buddies in tobacco land that that would be worth suffering through
another 9-11. Once you give the man that – and for once I
am asking you to do just that – once you admit that not even
he would allow the murder of hundreds or thousands more just so
Marlboro addicts can light up outside the terminal, then a whole
other door opens – and that door, my friends, leads to the
Pandora's Box of 9-11, a rotten can of worms that many in the media
are afraid to open for fear of where it might lead, of just how
deep the stench goes.
What if there is no "terrorist threat?" What if Bush and Co. need,
desperately need, that "terrorist threat" more than anything in
order to conduct the systematic destruction they have launched against
the U.S. constitution and the good people of this country who believe
in the freedoms and liberties it guarantees?
Do you want to go there?
I do. I have filed a Freedom of Information Act demand to the
FAA, asking that they give to me all documents pertaining to the
decisions that were made to allow deadly butane lighters and books
of matches on board passenger planes. I am not optimistic about
what the results of this will be.
And let's face it – it's just one small piece of the puzzle.
It is, after all, just a 99-cent Bic lighter. But, friends, I have
to tell you, over the years I have found that it is PRECISELY the
"little stories" and the "minor details" that contain within them
the LARGER truths. Perhaps my quest to find out why the freedom
to be able to start a fire on board a plane-full of citizens is
more important than yours or my life will be in vain. Or maybe,
just maybe, it will be the beginning of the end of this corrupt,
banal administration of con artists who shamelessly use the dead
of that day in September as the cover to get away with anything.
I think it's time we all stood up and started asking some questions
of these individuals. The bottom line: Anyone who would brazenly
steal an election and insert themselves into OUR White House with
zero mandate from The People is, frankly – sadly – capable